Probably Stolen Security investigation: how evidence builds and how to stop an arrest
How Security's case file, evidence meter, fines, arrests and executions work in Probably Stolen, and the Fixers and bribes that stop them.

Quick answer
A Probably Stolen Security investigation starts with a case file. Every contraband sale adds its value to it, and the file loses 20 a night per crime type until the investigation meter reaches 80. Keep it under 100 and the meter never moves. Let it grow and an officer is sent, and the size of the file decides the result: a fine under 300, an arrest from 300 and an execution from 1,500. Sell to Black Market and Revolution buyers, hide your stock and pay a Fixer when the file gets away from you.
Probably Stolen has two separate ways to ruin your week with Security, and most people only notice one. Inspections are the random visits where an officer searches your shop. A Probably Stolen Security investigation is the slow part: a bloody file with your name on it that grows every time you sell something dodgy. Passing an inspection does nothing for the file. I’d read the Security Record before selling anything risky, but we’ll get to that.
Security inspections
Inspections are random and turn up more often the more you traffic. The officer goes through the counter, the back room and the display case, and he skips anything in a Smuggler’s Bay or behind a lock. What he does with contraband depends on its tier.
| Tier | Sale markup | If it’s found |
|---|---|---|
| Low Level | +35% | Generally ignored |
| Mid Level | +70% | Seized |
| High Level | +100% | Seized and you’re fined |
| Critical Level | +150% | Shop shut for good and an immediate arrest |
Whatever the tier, finding any of it costs you Security reputation. Keep contraband out of the display case altogether. I’d treat that box as a home for food and nothing else. The Mentor’s own note says you’ll be arrested for it, and I’m not going to argue with him. Off-duty officers shop at your window as well, and anything illegal on the counter while they’re there is confiscated and fined.
How a Probably Stolen Security investigation builds
This is the quiet one, and it’s the one that ends runs. Every contraband sale puts its negotiated price on a file, filed under a crime type such as narcotics trafficking. Selling stolen goods adds to a stolen goods entry, selling mislabelled water or a bad chemical adds fraud or endangerment, and bribes get their own line.
What counts toward the file
Who you sell to changes what counts. Black Market buyers add half the value, the Revolution a third and the Cartel nothing. The Intimidating perk cuts new evidence by a third, and Blabbermouth adds a third on top.
How fast the meter climbs
Every night each crime type loses 20, for as long as the investigation meter is under 80. Whatever is left decides how far the meter climbs.
| File size after the nightly drop | Meter gain per night |
|---|---|
| Under 100 | 0 |
| 100 to 299 | +2 |
| 300 to 849 | +6 |
| 850 to 1,199 | +9 |
| 1,200 to 1,499 | +12 |
| 1,500 to 2,499 | +20 |
| 2,500 and up | +33 |
A small example. Sell 90 credits of Dream Dust to a buyer who counts in full and the file sits at 90. Overnight it drops to 70, then 50, and the meter never moves. Now sell 250 of narcotics and 120 of stolen goods in a day. After one night’s drop that’s 230 and 100, a file of 330, and the meter climbs 6 a night for as long as it stays that size.
Once the meter reaches 80 the nightly drop stops, which is the point where waiting no longer works. Your Security reputation changes the speed too. At +60 the nightly gain is halved, at -20 it’s about 20% faster and at -60 it’s 50% faster. Upper Levels at -60 piles another 50% on top.
How a Probably Stolen Security investigation ends
Once the meter fills, an officer is sent, and the size of the file at that moment decides what he does.
| File size | Outcome |
|---|---|
| Under 300 | A fine equal to the file, which also clears it and costs 10 Security reputation |
| 300 to 1,499 | Arrest |
| 1,500 and up | Execution |
An arrest or an execution finishes your run, and a fine you can’t pay does the same. If the file is empty by the time he turns up, nothing happens. That gives you one last chance to shrink it, which means a full meter isn’t the end of the road.
How to stop a Probably Stolen Security investigation
The Mentor hands you a Security Record, a copy of the file the department keeps on you, and it’s the one page that shows your case and your meter. Open it before you sell anything risky. Then pick your tools. I’d go for a Fixer the first time the file passes 300 and not before.
Wild’s Fixers
Call Joe Wild’s assistant on 8376, open Wild’s Network and look under Informant. Each tier needs the one before it, and each night you pay the fee it shaves a percentage off every crime type separately and then a flat amount on top.
| Tier | Unlock | Nightly fee | Cut per crime type |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixers I | 350 | 25 | 15%, then 50 more |
| Fixers II | 450 | 45 | 20%, then 150 more |
| Fixers III | 550 | 70 | 25%, then 400 more |
Those are Price Gouge and Mark Up prices. Unlocks cost 1.5 times as much on Thin Margins and double on Red Ink. Turn the service on after a heavy sales day and off again once the file is near zero.

Evidence Removal, warnings and Clemency
Evidence Removal is the emergency button for a meter that’s already high. It costs 500 credits, another 100 every time you use it, and you have to wait two weeks before using it again, which rules out leaning on it.
Inspection Early Warning costs 300 to unlock and 10 a night. It warns you about routine inspections so you can hide your stock, though not about surprise ones. Clemency is a one-use pass that costs 250, plus 100 for each later one, and it turns an inspection that would have put you in prison into a warning.
Bribes and VIP
Bribes only work on the Shady Security Inspector. The price is 100 plus 2 for each day, minus 2 for each point of Security reputation, held between 40 and 400. That ends the inspection, though it logs a bribery entry against you. At +100 Security reputation (VIP) the routine inspections and thieves stop, but an open case carries on regardless.
Selling without ruining yourself
Sell narcotics to Black Market and Revolution buyers first, because they add far less to the file. Put legal products between your contraband sales so the day’s total stays small. Keep stock in the Smuggler’s Bay and out of the display case. If you’re making Dream Dust for the Cartel, sales to Cartel buyers add nothing to the file at all.

Stop selling the moment the meter reaches 80, and check the Security Record every morning. That’s the whole Probably Stolen Security investigation system. It’s dull, and it’s what keeps you out of a cell.
Did this guide help?
Up next in Probably Stolen
Something wrong or out of date? Tell us
Guide by
Josh
Josh plays a lot of Arc Raiders and yells “friendly!” into proximity chat more than he should. He gets shot anyway. He’s also a horror fan who has quit more games at the first jump scare than he’ll admit, and he runs a Supermarket Simulator shop he’s weirdly proud of.

Squad chat
Be the firstStart the chat