Probably Stolen tips and tricks: what to do after week one
Haggling, appraisals, Joe Wild's network, night trips and who to report once you're past week one in Probably Stolen.

Quick answer
Pick one lane and stock for it, haggle sparingly because every bargain nudges faction reputation, and take the Appraisal Board’s offer on day 8 for 85 credits. Keep power and insurance on every night, report only the wanted customers you can’t make money from, and never call Security on an Aug.
Once week one is out of the way, Probably Stolen throws a lot at you at once. Joe Wild turns up with his network, you can start haggling, the appraisers come knocking and around day 12 the Mentor mentions a rogue AI that’s been taking over people’s heads. Most of these systems don’t explain themselves very well.
Pick a focus
Your shop only has so much room and you can’t do everything, so choose a lane. At the start that’s food and drink, because everyone buys it and it’s cheap to move. Later it might be machines, a chemistry setup, water or farming, and the game hands you a starting kit for most of those. Being a bit of everything sounds clever for about three days, until your storage bay is full of scrap nobody wants. I’d still hold a little of everything else back in case someone asks.
Read the news and set the case
The daily newspaper and the chatter at your window are how you find out what’s coming. A Bad Nutrifruit Harvest pushes food prices up by half for three days, a Water Supply Crisis doubles water, and surpluses push prices the other way. Buy before the shortage, sell during it, and put the right sign in the display case, which pulls in the people who want it. Event days often bring an extra customer tied to the event as well.

On a quiet day, put whatever you’ve got too much of in the case so somebody turns up to buy it. If you’re short of something, a sign for it brings a seller. The value of what you put in matters more than the number of items, because a pricier item pulls in a buyer with a bigger budget.
Haggle sparingly
Bargaining unlocks on day 8 when the Mentor teaches it. Open the tablet, open the negotiation box and hit the speech bubble. From there you can charge more or offer a discount. Customers who get a good deal tell their faction, and customers who feel robbed do the same, so I’d treat haggling as a reputation tool first and a way to make money a distant second. A small discount for a faction you want on your side costs a few credits and is usually money well spent.
Your difficulty scales all of it. Price Gouge multiplies reputation gains by 1.5 and halves the losses, Mark Up leaves them alone, and Red Ink halves your gains and doubles your losses.
Two options in the bargain panel are for specific situations. Threaten (Aug) only works on an Aug and Blackmail (Criminal) only works on a wanted criminal. Try either on anyone else and it fails and costs you reputation.
Join the Appraisal Board
On day 8 a rep from the Appraisal Board walks in and offers you membership for 85 credits (skip the intro and it’s day 5). You get a Junior certificate, a guide to cybernetic hands and a magnifying glass, and it’s cheap money for very little risk. Put the certificate in your display case and appraisal customers start turning up. Each one brings two to four items. You look at them through the magnifying glass, check the guide and send an estimate. Get within 5% of the true value either way and it’s graded Perfect, which pays a 20 credit base fee plus 15% of your estimate. Three refused estimates and the customer leaves.

Do it all the time. The certificate doesn’t stop the case attracting other customers, so there’s no reason to take it down. When the progress bar on your certificate fills, a board member comes back with a promotion offer, 106 credits on Mark Up for the first one, and you can pay, ask him back in a week or turn it down for good. Ten Perfect estimates also get you an achievement.
Joe Wild’s network
Joe Wild turns up on day 4 to sell you insurance and on day 7 he gives you his business card. Pick up the phone, call his assistant on 8376 and choose Browse Wild’s Service and you’re in his upgrade shop. You pay in Wild’s Favor first and in credits only for whatever the favor doesn’t cover. You earn favor from your standing with the Lower Levels and from using his nightly services.

On Mark Up the cheap early picks are Rent Grace at 100 favor, which gives you the Landlord’s grace back once you’ve burned it, and Buyer Referral Service at 200, which sends extra customers your way. Red Imp Brewery gets you legal beer to resell, and Water Trading and Winemaking are in there too if you fancy one of those lanes, along with a vending machine that sells your leftovers overnight. I’d start with the cheap stuff and let the favor build, rather than blow credits on the big upgrades before you’ve paid your first couple of rents.
Night trips and Dr. Jackson
Once the Mentor has shown you the way on day 2, you can head out after closing, but only to one place a night. The Dumping Grounds are open first and that’s where you scavenge for things to sell. Dr. Jackson’s place and the Commissary open up later. The cost is that your shop opens late the next morning and you miss a customer, so I’d only go out when there’s a reason. Being low on stock and credits is a good one.
You get up to five searches in the Dumping Grounds and the longer you keep digging the likelier you are to get hurt. The Mentor hands you a fanny pack and a bandage on day 2, so take the bandage every time and clear your counter before you leave, because you’ll want the space for whatever comes back. Dr. Jackson turns up at your window around day 6 and his own shop is shut on Mondays. A satchel from him is the first upgrade I’d buy, since a bigger bag means a better haul.
Nightly fees and break-ins
Power runs 5 or 6 credits a night, insurance 5 to 8 and the janitor 4. Keep power and insurance on. Without insurance a thief has a 33% chance of breaking in every night, and it creeps up by 5% for each night in a row you go without. With it the odds drop to around 6% and Wild’s men bring the item back if it does happen. A thief only ever takes one item, which sounds fine until it’s your best one.
The janitor is the one to skip when you’re skint. Rubbish out front drags your store’s attractiveness down from 250 towards 175 over a few nights, which costs you a few customers and recovers once the janitor has been round. Pay for him when the nightly report mentions rubbish.
Counterfeits
Not everything that comes over the counter is what the label says. Use the magnifying glass before you buy anything that can be faked and look for an actual fault, like the seals or markings on a pack of cigarettes. When the game lets you pick the fault, use Confront. Get it right and the seller has to rethink the offer. Miss, and you lose reputation while the customer walks. A suspiciously low price proves nothing on its own. If you can’t point at the problem, either buy it or pass.


Reputation and who to report
Every faction on the station keeps its own score for you, and almost everyone at your window belongs to one. The reputation box by the door shows them. You’ll meet the Lower Levels, Upper Levels, Security, Black Market and Revolution, plus the Sector 13 Cartel if you started as a Chemist. Selling earns you reputation. A correct report earns +5 with Security, while the criminal’s faction takes the hit.

Go too low and it bites. At -40 with Security your alarms stop working, at -80 the inspectors get thorough and drop in more often, and at -80 with the Lower Levels every supplier refuses your calls. At -100, any of the Lower Levels, Upper Levels, Security or Revolution means game over. Black Market has no -100 penalty, and Chemists add the Cartel to the list.
That’s why I’d think twice before reporting anyone. Odin Haraldsson is worth 300 credits and walks in around day 10, but he belongs to the Revolution. James Bailey is Lower Levels. Report them and those factions remember. Odin also buys firearms, ammunition, melee weapons, armour and access cards, so he’s worth more as a regular than as a one-off bounty. A false report costs you 8 Security reputation and 50 credits if you’ve got them, though the game forgives one false report every five days. My rule is that if a wanted face turns into a regular buyer I leave them alone, and if they don’t I take the bounty.
Augs

Around day 12 the Mentor gives you the Aug talk. They’re people taken over by a rogue AI in a brain implant. They go after raw materials and medical supplies, so anyone asking for those deserves extra suspicion. Look for a chip at the temple or forehead, odd pupils and a fixed grin, then stiff stillness or twitching, an outfit that doesn’t match the faction on the panel, and robotic or overly formal speech. One tell proves nothing.

Don’t call Security on a suspected Aug. They’ve hacked the comms and leave before anyone arrives. The shotgun under the counter can only be equipped on days Security warns you about one, and the Mentor’s rule is to shoot only when you’re completely sure.
Dr. Jackson sells an Aug Scanner that confirms one with 100% accuracy, which beats a hunch. Letting too many Augs walk away ends your run on Thin Margins and Red Ink, and on every difficulty if you took the Aug Menace perk.

Save for the shop
The deed costs 12,000 credits on Mark Up. The price stays put until day 50, then climbs by 50 a day until it caps at 17,000. You pay in cash, and the estimated total wealth on the status tab counts your stock and machines, which the landlord doesn’t care about, so watch your credits instead. Buy the deed before day 50 and you also get the Prodigious achievement.
If you can’t find the cash, the Loan Shark offers a mortgage early on. On Mark Up that’s 2,000 up front and then 930 a week for 12 weeks, which adds up to 13,160 credits against 12,000 outright. The weekly payment replaces your rent. Miss one and he repossesses your stock, and if there’s not enough stock to take, the run ends in repossession.
Did this guide help?
Up next in Probably Stolen
Something wrong or out of date? Tell us
Guide by
Josh
Josh plays a lot of Arc Raiders and yells “friendly!” into proximity chat more than he should. He gets shot anyway. He’s also a horror fan who has quit more games at the first jump scare than he’ll admit, and he runs a Supermarket Simulator shop he’s weirdly proud of.

Squad chat
Be the firstStart the chat