CheckpointGuides
Probably StolenEarly game Spoilers

Probably Stolen wanted list: who to report and who to let walk

Nine wanted customers walk into your shop and only one is worth turning in. Every bounty, the revenge storylines and what each one gives you for letting them go.

Published
Patch
Hotfix 1.0.0.5
Read
6 min read
Wanted poster board with bounties on James Bailey, The Butcher and Arthur Lafleur in Probably Stolen

Spoiler warning. This guide names bosses, areas or story moments. Bigger reveals stay hidden in spoiler blocks until you open them.

Quick answer

Report Leroy every time he shows up and let the other eight walk. Arthur Lafleur gets one trick: press the alarm once so he makes his plea, then dismiss him for +15 Revolution reputation. The bounties add up to 3,600 credits, but Lou, the Butcher and John Smith all cost you more than they pay.

Officer Lun hands you the Wanted List on Day 1 and it feels like free money. Nine faces, nine bounties, a teal button next to the till that turns a stranger into credits. I’d leave that button alone for most of them. Half the list is worth more standing at the window in Probably Stolen than sitting in a cell, and a few come back angry if you cash them in. If your first week is still a blur, get the basics down before you start arresting people.

Probably Stolen wanted list

All nine below, with the base bounty and what you get for leaving them alone. Perks change the numbers, and I get to those at the end.

CustomerBountyReport?What you get for letting them go
Lou1,500SpareStays a customer who buys melee weapons and tools. Report her and a bomb storyline starts
The Butcher450SpareComes back every 7 days with cheap raw meat. Report him and he vandalises your shop
Li Bei Wen400SpareTakes chemical packs off you, then hands over the Nomore formula and two high-purity injectors
James Bailey300SpareSells stolen Security equipment every 14 days
Odin Haraldsson300SpareGives you a Revolution contact for weapons and ammo
Leroy300ReportFake Security inspector who is really a thief
Juan125SpareFood supplier who returns about every 8 days
John Smith125SpareWeekly food buyer with a budget that keeps growing
Arthur Lafleur100Plea trick+15 Revolution reputation if you play it right

Add the bounties up and it’s 3,600 credits, which sounds great until you read the right-hand column. Injectors, a phone contact and weekly food money beat almost any single payout on that list.

How to report a wanted customer

Open the Wanted List from your documents and check the face before you touch anything. The customer label is no help (half of them just say Lower Level Citizen). Once you’re sure, hold the teal Call Security button for about half a second while they’re still at the window. A quick click does nothing, so it feels broken when it isn’t. Miss one and nothing happens. The next Nightly Report tells you who walked past and that’s the end of it.

The poster is a three by three grid, and every face has one thing you can lock onto. James Bailey is bald with an eyepatch. The Butcher wears a flat cap and has a heavy, lined face. Arthur Lafleur has a dark knitted beanie and a high collar. Odin Haraldsson wears a beanie too, but his comes with a thick beard. Lou has long pale hair, and Li Bei Wen has short dark hair and a serious stare. Juan has a cap and a moustache. John Smith is bald with nothing else going on, so check for the eyepatch before you mix him up with Bailey. Leroy is a beret and a short beard, and he arrives posing as a Security inspector.

Hooded customer in a mask at the shop window in Probably Stolen

Three officers walk in, arrest them and take them out, and the bounty lands once they’ve gone. You get +5 Security reputation too, and a banner tells you how the criminal’s own crowd (Revolution, Lower Levels, whoever) took it. Most of the list costs you 6 points with their own faction for the privilege. The Butcher is the happy exception and gives you +6 with the Lower Levels, and Leroy and Lou cost you nothing.

The Butcher in his red cap and bloody apron at the shop window with a Security officer on either side in Probably Stolen

Don’t guess. A wrong report costs 8 Security reputation and a 50-credit fine if you’re holding 100 or more. One wrong report is forgiven every five days, so a single mistake fades. Keep guessing and it doesn’t, and by the fourth you’re being warned that the next one gets you arrested.

Leroy: the one to report

Leroy comes in saying he’s from Security and wants a look round the shop, when what he actually wants is your stock. Going along with the inspection doesn’t save you either, because he still helps himself. Report him. You get 300 credits and the Security reputation, and nobody on the list has mates who’ll be upset about it, so there’s no downside at all.

Real Security investigations happen too, so match the face to the portrait before you hit anything. Nothing else is going to save you if you get it wrong.

Lou’s bomb storyline

Lou pays the most (1,500 credits) and that bounty is the whole trap. She only turns up once you’ve bought the Business Permit, so don’t expect her early. Report her and she’s back three days later planting a bomb in one of your containers. That one’s fake and defuses itself overnight, but it starts a run of visits you can’t dodge. Then she leaves a Box of Toys with you. Don’t touch it. Every item inside stays inside, even the stuff you’d normally sell without thinking, because lose the box or any one thing from it and the next bomb is a real fucking bomb, and that ends your run.

Spoiler: Lou’s 1,500 credit demand

A few days after she collects the box, someone posing as a Security inspector turns up and turns out to be her. She wants 1,500 credits and gives you seven days to find them. She takes weapons, ammunition and medical supplies at a discounted value and cash for whatever’s missing. Cover her minimum and she leaves you alone for good. Fall short of it and the bomb is real.

So the bounty is a loan. She pays you 1,500 and later sends the bill for 1,500, mostly in stock you’d have sold for more. Let her go and she’s a plain customer who buys melee weapons and tools, and nothing else happens. I’d only report her if you’ve got the stock to pay her off and the patience to babysit a box for a week and a bit. Most runs have neither.

The Butcher’s revenge

Red cap, bloody apron, raw meat at a decent discount. Spare him and he’s back about every seven days with more.

Butcher in a bloody apron waiting at the counter in Probably Stolen

Report him and you pick up 450 credits plus some Lower Levels goodwill, because they can’t stand him either. Then you pay for it. Around six days after the arrest your shop front has MEAT scrawled across it and fewer customers turn up that day. Three days after that a cleaver arrives with a threatening note, and the message is to arm yourself before you set foot outside.

Shotgun lying across the counter next to the inventory grid in Probably Stolen

Sawyer turns up a day or so later selling his Butcher Hunting Service. It costs 500 credits and paying him is what ends it. So you took 450, paid out 500, and you’re 50 down, plus a shit day of trade, plus the cleaning. I’d spare him every time.

John Smith

John Smith pays 125 credits and he’s the worst bounty on the list. He buys food every seven days and his budget grows as the game goes on, so he’s basically a small pension. Report him once and the weekly visits stop. He comes back one last time two days later, and if you report him again he sprays his own name across your shop front the next night, which is a hell of a way to say thanks and costs you customers. A third report finishes it. Three bounties of 125 get you 375 credits and a clean-up job, against a customer who’d spend that on food week after week.

Li Bei Wen, Odin and the rest

Li Bei Wen is worth 400 credits and a lot more alive. He sells you a batch of Nomore injectors first, then comes back wanting chemical packs. Keep him supplied over a few visits and he finishes by handing over the Nomore formula and two injectors at 99% purity or better. Arrest him halfway and every visit he had left is cancelled, so the formula never turns up. Four hundred credits for losing the recipe is a rubbish trade.

Spare Odin Haraldsson and he hands you a contact card, which lets you phone him to trade weapons and ammunition. He arrives two days after the call, and you can dial him again once five days have passed since the last one. Report him and the Revolution phone line goes dead, and some Revolution reputation goes with it.

Arthur Lafleur is the first wanted face you’ll meet, around Day 3. Press Call Security once and let him make his plea, then dismiss him without pressing it again. You get 15 Revolution reputation instead of the 100 credits. Dismiss him without the plea and you get nothing at all.

Juan and James Bailey are suppliers. Juan sells stolen food at a discount and comes back about every eight days. James sells stolen Security equipment every two weeks, and arresting him costs you standing with the Lower Levels. Both are cheaper to keep than to lock up.

Perks that change the bounties

Model Citizen adds 50% to every bounty, so Lou pays 2,250 and Leroy pays 450, and it starts you on +30 Security reputation. Convict takes 25% off, so Lou pays 1,125, and starts you on -30. Known Snitch stops wanted customers from visiting at all. That sounds like peace and quiet until you notice it also stops Li Bei Wen and Odin showing up.

If you’re skint in the first week, Leroy’s 300 is real money and I wouldn’t blame anyone for taking it. There are quicker ways to build cash once you’re past that, and the rest of the list can keep walking in.

Up next in Probably Stolen

Something wrong or out of date? Tell us

Guide by

Josh

Josh plays a lot of Arc Raiders and yells “friendly!” into proximity chat more than he should. He gets shot anyway. He’s also a horror fan who has quit more games at the first jump scare than he’ll admit, and he runs a Supermarket Simulator shop he’s weirdly proud of.

Squad chat

Be the first
Start the chat

Join the chat